Should We Go Extinct!: A Philosophical Dilemma for Our Unbearable Times BY Todd May

Should we bring new humans into the world? Or would it be better off without us? Renowned philosopher and advisor to NBC’s The Good Place, Todd May, offers a thoughtful exploration of humanity’s future—or lack thereof—in Should We Go Extinct?.

“For more than five years, Todd May was my philosophical advisor. I heartily recommend that he be yours as well. (It helps that he’s quite funny.),” writes Michael Schur in the Introduction.

In an age where climate destruction and nuclear threats loom large, philosopher Todd May confronts the unsettling question: would the world be better off without humans? This timely examination delves into the balance of humanity's positive and negative impacts on the planet and each other. May, known for his work on The Good Place, presents arguments for and against the continuation of our species, aiming to assess the true value of human existence.

May explores the unique contributions humans make, such as art and music, and the value of human relationships. However, he also scrutinizes the immense suffering we inflict on the natural world, challenging us to weigh these harms against our merits. He addresses critical issues like factory farming, animal testing, overpopulation, and the need for greater empathy towards other creatures.

In a time of growing pessimism about the future and questions about the ethics of bringing children into such a world, Should We Go Extinct? offers a nuanced perspective. May's exploration of these complex issues provides a framework for understanding our responsibilities as a species and offers hope that we can reach a consensus that humanity's existence should continue, albeit with significant changes.